Hipp vs. Holle Formula Comparison Guide: Which European Organic Baby Formula Is Best for Your Child?
🍼 OBF24™ BLOG
As a parent, choosing the right baby formula for your child can be a daunting task. With so many different brands and types of formula on the market, it can be overwhelming to know where to start. In this guide, we will be comparing two popular European organic baby formula brands: HiPP and Holle.
The Importance of Choosing Organic Baby Formula
When it comes to feeding your baby, you want to ensure that they are getting the best possible nutrition. Choosing Organic Baby Formula can help you achieve that goal. Organic baby formula is made without the use of synthetic pesticides, growth hormones, or genetically modified ingredients. This means that it is free from harmful chemicals and additives that could potentially harm your child's health.
Trusted Brands with a Longstanding Reputation
Holle and HiPP are well-established baby formula brands, with HiPP originating in Germany in 1899 and Holle beginning in Switzerland during the 1930s. Both companies have honed their expertise over the years, and their dedication to creating safe, simple, and nutritionally-complete formulas has earned them a reputable status.
Both Holle and HiPP have received approval and certification for being organic by the European Commission, which has more stringent regulations than the US Food and Drug Administration. All formulas produced by these brands adhere to these strict standards, but each formula has a unique combination of ingredients. As a result, it is essential to compare the macronutrients, micronutrients, and supplements in each formula when selecting the best one for your baby.
🍼 Hipp Formula Overview
Hipp is a German-based company that has been producing baby formula for over 60 years. They are known for their commitment to organic farming practices and using high-quality ingredients in their formulas. Hipp offers a range of formulas, including infant formula, follow-on formula, and toddler formula.
Hipp Infant Formula
Hipp Infant Formula is designed for babies from birth to 6 months old. It is made with organic skim milk and whey, along with organic vegetable oils and a blend of vitamins and minerals. Hipp Infant Formula is also free from added sugars, gluten, and soy.
Hipp Follow-On Formula
Hipp Follow-On Formula is designed for babies from 6 months old onwards. It is made with a similar blend of organic ingredients as their Infant Formula, but with added iron and vitamin D. Hipp Follow-On Formula is also free from added sugars, gluten, and soy.
Hipp Toddler Formula
Hipp Toddler Formula is designed for children from 10 months old onwards. It is made with organic skim milk, organic vegetable oils, and a blend of vitamins and minerals. Hipp Toddler Formula also contains prebiotics and probiotics to support digestive health.
🍼 Holle Formula Overview
Holle is a Swiss-based company that has been producing baby formula for over 80 years. They are known for their commitment to biodynamic farming practices and using only the highest quality ingredients in their formulas. Holle offers a range of formulas, including infant formula, follow-on formula, and growing-up formula.
Holle Infant Formula
Holle Infant Formula is designed for babies from birth to 6 months old. It is made with organic skim milk and whey, along with organic vegetable oils and a blend of vitamins and minerals. Holle Infant Formula is also free from added sugars, gluten, and soy.
Holle Follow-On Formula
Holle Follow-On Formula is designed for babies from 6 months old onwards. It is made with a similar blend of organic ingredients as their Infant Formula, but with added iron and vitamin D. Holle Follow-On Formula is also free from added sugars, gluten, and soy.
Holle Growing-Up Formula
Holle Growing-Up Formula is designed for children from 10 months old onwards. It is made with organic skim milk, organic vegetable oils, and a blend of vitamins and minerals. Holle Growing-Up Formula also contains prebiotics and probiotics to support digestive health.
Hipp vs. Holle: Ingredient Comparison
When comparing Hipp and Holle formulas, you'll notice that they have similar ingredient lists. Both companies use organic skim milk, organic vegetable oils, and a blend of vitamins and minerals in their formulas. However, there are some differences in the specific ingredients used.
Milk Source
Hipp and Holle both use organic cow's milk in their formulas. However, there is a difference in the source of the milk. Hipp sources their milk from free-range cows that are raised on biodynamic farms. Holle sources most of their milk from Demeter-certified biodynamic farms, which have even higher standards for animal welfare and farming practices.
Vegetable Oil Blend
Both Hipp and Holle use a blend of organic vegetable oils in their formulas. However, the specific oils used are different. Hipp uses a blend of organic palm oil, rapeseed oil, sunflower oil, and coconut oil. Holle uses a blend of organic palm oil, rapeseed oil, and sunflower oil.
Prebiotics and Probiotics
Breast milk is rich in both prebiotics and probiotics, which help to promote the growth of beneficial gut bacteria in a baby's digestive system and enhance the immune system. Probiotics are particularly helpful for digestion and have been shown to alleviate colic, prevent eczema, and improve immune response. Holle offers a simplified formula with a short list of ingredients and therefore does not include prebiotics or probiotics. However, pre- and probiotic supplements are available for purchase and can be added to their formula. In contrast, all HiPP formulas include prebiotics, and HiPP's Hypoallergenic, Anti-Reflux, Comfort formulas contain both prebiotics and probiotics.
Nutritional Comparison
When it comes to nutrition, both Hipp and Holle formulas meet the European Union's strict standards for infant and follow-on formulas. However, there are some differences in the specific nutrients and levels used.
Protein
Hipp and Holle formulas both contain a similar amount of protein, with Hipp containing 1.3g per 100ml and Holle containing 1.4g per 100ml.
Fat
Hipp and Holle formulas both contain a similar amount of fat, with Hipp containing 3.5g per 100ml and Holle containing 3.6g per 100ml.
Carbohydrates
Hipp and Holle formulas both contain a similar amount of carbohydrates, with Hipp containing 7.3g per 100ml and Holle containing 7.1g per 100ml.
Vitamins and Minerals
Hipp and Holle formulas both contain a similar blend of vitamins and minerals. However, there are some differences in the specific levels used. For example, Hipp contains more vitamin A and vitamin C than Holle, while Holle contains more vitamin E and vitamin K.
Price Comparison
When it comes to price, Hipp and Holle formulas are both more expensive than standard formula made in North America. However, there are some differences in the specific prices.
Infant Formula
Hipp Infant Formula is slightly more expensive than Holle Infant Formula. A 900g box of Hipp Infant Formula costs around $36, while a 600g box of Holle Infant Formula costs around $29.
Follow-On Formula
Holle Follow-On Formula is slightly more expensive than Hipp Follow-On Formula. A 600g box of Holle Follow-On Formula costs around $29, while a 800g box of Hipp Follow-On Formula costs around $36.
Toddler Formula
Hipp Toddler Formula is slightly more expensive than Holle Toddler Formula. A 600g box of Hipp Toddler Formula costs around $36, while a 600g box of Holle Toddler Formula costs around $29.
Conclusion
When it comes to choosing between Hipp and Holle formulas, both are excellent options for parents looking for high-quality, organic baby formula. Both companies use high-quality, organic ingredients and meet the European Union's strict standards for infant and follow-on formulas.
While there are some differences in the specific ingredients and nutritional levels used, the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference and budget. Hipp formulas are slightly more expensive than Holle formulas, but they also source their milk from free-range cows that are raised on biodynamic farms. Holle formulas, on the other hand, are slightly less expensive but still use organic milk from Demeter-certified biodynamic farms.
No matter which brand you choose, you can be confident that you are providing your child with the best possible nutrition.
FAQs
1) 💭 What is the difference between European organic formula and standard formula made in North America?
European organic formula is made without the use of synthetic pesticides, growth hormones, or genetically modified ingredients. Standard formula made in North America may contain these additives.
2) 💭 Are Hipp and Holle formulas gluten-free?
Yes, both Hipp and Holle formulas are gluten-free.
3) 💭 Are Hipp and Holle formulas suitable for babies with lactose intolerance?
No, Hipp and Holle formulas are not suitable for babies with lactose intolerance. However, they do offer lactose-free formulas.
4) 💭 Can I mix Hipp and Holle formulas together?
We do not recommend mixing different brands of formula together as they may have different nutrient levels and could cause digestive issues for your baby.
5) 💭 Can I purchase Hipp and Holle formulas in North America?
Yes, you can purchase Hipp and Holle formulas online from retailers that specialize in European baby formula. However, they may be more expensive than standard formula made in North America.
6) 💭 Why is HiPP the best formula?
HiPP is known for their commitment to organic farming practices and using high-quality ingredients in their formulas. They also source their milk from free-range cows that are raised on biodynamic farms. However, the choice of the "best" formula ultimately comes down to personal preference and budget.
7) 💭 Why is HiPP not sold in the US?
HiPP is not currently sold in the US due to regulatory barriers and the high cost of entering the US market.
8) 💭 Is Holle a good formula?
Yes, Holle is known for their commitment to biodynamic farming practices and using only the highest quality ingredients in their formulas. They also meet the European Union's strict standards for infant and follow-on formulas.
9) 💭 Are HiPP and Holle FDA approved?
No, HiPP and Holle are not FDA approved as they are not sold in the US. However, they do meet the European Union's strict standards for infant and follow-on formulas.
10) 💭 What is the best organic baby formula?
The choice of the "best" organic baby formula ultimately comes down to personal preference and budget. Both HiPP and Holle are excellent options for parents looking for high-quality, organic baby formula.
11) 💭 What formula milk is closest to breast milk?
While no formula can fully replicate breast milk, formulas that contain a blend of whey and casein proteins, such as HiPP and Holle, are thought to be closest to breast milk. These formulas also contain a similar ratio of fats and carbohydrates to breast milk.
